I've spent way too much money on barbecue gear.
I'm not proud of it. There was a period in my first year where I was convinced that the only thing standing between me and competition glory was the right piece of equipment. I bought fancy thermometers. I bought expensive rubs in tins that looked like they belonged in a museum. I bought a custom-made butcher paper holder that cost forty bucks and did exactly the same thing as a roll of paper towels.
I look back on that version of myself and I want to shake him. The equipment doesn't make the pitmaster. The pitmaster makes the equipment. And most of the stuff they sell you? You don't need it.
So here's my honest, no-BS guide to what's actually worth your money and what's a total waste. This is the gear I use, the gear I've burned through, and the gear I've learned to ignore.
What's Worth Your Money
A Decent Thermometer ($40–$80)
This is the one thing I will never compromise on. A good thermometer is the difference between a brisket that's perfectly tender and a brisket that's shoe leather. I use a ThermoPop, which costs about forty bucks. It's fast, it's accurate, and it's reliable.
I also use a wireless probe thermometer for long smokes. I've got a Thermoworks Signals that I've been using for three years. It's not cheap, but it's saved me from panicking more times than I can count. When I can see the temperature from my phone, I don't have to stand outside staring at the smoker like a worried parent.
What I don't do is buy the cheap ones from the hardware store. I've been through six of them. They all broke within a month.
A Good Spritz Bottle ($10)
This is one of the cheapest and most useful tools I own. A heavy-duty spray bottle with a mist setting. I use it to spritz my brisket and ribs with apple cider vinegar and water to keep the surface moist and help the bark set up.
The key is a fine mist, not a stream. If your spray bottle shoots a stream, it'll wash the rub right off your meat. Get one with a good nozzle. It'll cost you ten bucks and it'll last for years.
High-Quality Butcher Paper ($20–$30)
I'm a convert to butcher paper. I used to wrap briskets in foil, and they came out fine, but the bark was always a little sad. Butcher paper lets the meat breathe while keeping in the moisture. The bark stays bark, and the meat stays tender.
I use uncoated, unwaxed butcher paper. Pink butcher paper is the standard. It's not expensive, and a roll lasts me a whole season.
A Good Pair of Tongs ($20)
I've gone through more pairs of cheap tongs than I can remember. They bend, they lose their spring, and they drop your meat on the ground. I use a pair of heavy-duty, stainless steel tongs with good grip.
They don't need to be fancy. They just need to be solid.
What's Not Worth Your Money
Expensive Rubs in Fancy Tins ($15–$25)
I said this in a previous post, and I'll say it again. You don't need a $25 rub in a burlap bag. Salt, pepper, sugar, paprika, garlic powder. That's all you need. Everything else is marketing. If you want to spend money on rubs, go ahead, but you're paying for packaging, not flavor.
A $300 Custom Grill Grate
I almost bought one. I had it in my online cart. It was a fancy, custom-made grill grate that promised even heat distribution and perfect sear marks. I'm glad I didn't buy it. The stock grates that came with my smoker work perfectly fine.
The truth is, your cooking technique matters way more than your grill grates. If you can't manage your fire, no amount of fancy grates is going to save you.
Expensive Wood Chunks from Online Boutiques
I've bought wood chunks from specialty shops that cost twice as much as the ones at the hardware store. And you know what? I couldn't tell the difference. Wood is wood. As long as it's seasoned and dry, it works. My favorite source for wood chunks is the guy on Facebook Marketplace who sells them for ten bucks a bag.
A "BBQ Guru" Controller ($200+)
These are the devices that automatically control your smoker's temperature. You set it to 225, and it does the work for you. I get the appeal. But for me, they take the fun out of it. The whole point of smoking is learning to read the fire. Buying a device that does it for you is like buying a pre-made cake mix and pretending you baked it.
I've tried them. They work. But they're expensive, and they rob you of the experience.
What I Actually Use Every Time
Here's my honest list of the gear that's always on my patio table:
ThermoPop thermometer
Wireless probe thermometer (Thermoworks Signals)
Heavy-duty spray bottle
Butcher paper
Good tongs
A set of heat-resistant gloves
A headlamp for night smokes
That's it. That's the whole kit. Everything else is optional.
The Takeaway
The barbecue industry wants you to believe you need a thousand dollars' worth of gear to make good food. You don't. You need a smoker that holds heat, a thermometer that works, and the patience to learn how your fire behaves.
Everything else is just noise. Don't let the gear snobs convince you otherwise. Low and slow, and don't overthink it. And don't spend forty bucks on a butcher paper holder. Just don't.
No letters yet — be the first to write.